Back to bookA Study in Scarlet
Free sample
Free sample chapter
Chapter I

Mr Sherlock Holmes

In the year 1878 I became a Doctor of Medicine and trained as an army surgeon. Soon the second Afghan war began, and I joined my regiment in Afghanistan. At the terrible battle of Maiwand a bullet hit me in the shoulder and broke the bone. My orderly, a brave man called Murray, threw me across a pack-horse and carried me safely back to the British lines.

In the hospital I caught a dangerous fever, and for months the doctors thought that I would die. At last they sent me back to England. My health was ruined, and the government gave me nine months to try to improve it.

I had no family in England, so I went to London. I stayed in a hotel and spent my small army pension much faster than I should have. Soon I had to find cheaper rooms. On the very day I decided this, someone touched my shoulder in the Criterion Bar. It was young Stamford, who had worked under me at Barts hospital. I was so glad to see a friendly face that I invited him to lunch.

"What have you been doing to yourself, Watson?" he asked. "You're as thin as a stick, and you're so tanned."

I told him my story, and then explained that I was looking for rooms at a reasonable price.

"That's strange," he said. "You're the second man today who's said that to me. A man at the hospital laboratory wants someone to share some nice rooms with him. They're too expensive for him alone."

I said at once that I was exactly the person he needed. Stamford looked at me rather strangely. "You don't know Sherlock Holmes yet," he said. "His ideas are a little strange. He knows a lot about chemistry, but he isn't a medical student. And he's a little too scientific for my taste. I could imagine him giving a friend a little poison, just to see what happens. To be fair, he'd take it himself just as readily."

We found Holmes alone in the chemical laboratory, a large room full of bottles and little blue flames. When he saw us, he jumped up with a cry of joy.

"I've found it! I've found it!" he shouted, running towards us with a test-tube in his hand. "I've found a chemical that reacts with blood and with nothing else."

"Dr Watson, Mr Sherlock Holmes," said Stamford.

"How are you?" said Holmes, shaking my hand with surprising strength. "You've been in Afghanistan, I see."

"How on earth did you know that?" I asked in astonishment.

"Never mind," he said, laughing quietly. He put one drop of his own blood into a litre of water and added a few white crystals, and the water turned dark brown. With this test, he explained, the police could always tell if an old stain was blood.

Stamford explained why we had come, and Holmes was pleased. "I've got my eye on some rooms in Baker Street," he said. "You don't mind strong tobacco? I often do chemical experiments. And sometimes I get into bad moods and don't speak for days. Just leave me alone then. What are your faults? Two people should know the worst about each other before they live together."

I laughed. "I keep a bulldog puppy, I don't like noise because my nerves are bad, I get up at strange hours, and I'm extremely lazy."

"Do you count violin-playing as noise?" he asked anxiously.

"It depends on the player," I answered, and he laughed. That settled it.

As we walked away, I asked Stamford how Holmes had known about Afghanistan. Stamford only smiled. "That's his little secret. I bet he learns more about you than you learn about him."

The next day we took the rooms at 221B Baker Street: two comfortable bedrooms and a large, bright sitting-room. Holmes was not a difficult man to live with. Sometimes he worked all day with great energy. At other times he lay on the sofa for days, hardly saying a word.

He was over six feet tall and very thin, with sharp eyes and a nose like the beak of a hawk. His hands were always stained with ink and chemicals. My health kept me at home, I had no friends, and this man was a mystery that I wanted to solve.

His knowledge was very strange. He knew almost nothing about literature, philosophy or politics. One day I discovered that he did not know that the earth goes round the sun.

"Now that I know it, I'll do my best to forget it," he said.

"To forget it!"

"You see," he explained, "a man's brain is like a little empty attic, a small room at the top of a house. A fool fills it with every kind of rubbish. A skilled worker keeps only the tools that help him in his work. If we went round the moon, it would make no difference to my work."

I wanted to ask what his work was, but I did not dare. Instead I made a list of what he knew: poisons, chemistry, British law, the soils of London, and every terrible crime of the century. He also played the violin well and was a good boxer. I could not imagine a job that needed all these things, so I threw my list into the fire.

He had many strange visitors. A small, dark-eyed man called Mr Lestrade came three or four times a week. "These people are my clients," Holmes told me.

On the 4th of March I picked up a magazine and read an article called "The Book of Life". The writer said that a trained observer could learn everything about a man from small details: his fingernails, his coat-sleeve, his boots, his face.

"What nonsense!" I said.

"I wrote the article myself," said Holmes calmly. "I make my living from these ideas. I'm a consulting detective. I suppose I'm the only one in the world. When the police have a difficult case, they come to me. Lestrade is a well-known detective from Scotland Yard.

"When we first met, you were surprised that I knew you had come from Afghanistan. I didn't guess. My mind worked like this: here is a man who looks like a doctor, but he moves like a soldier. So he's an army doctor. His face is dark, but his wrists are white, so he's been in a hot country. His face is thin and tired, so he's been ill. He holds his left arm stiffly, so it was wounded. Where could an English army doctor have suffered like this? Clearly in Afghanistan. The whole thought took less than a second."

"It's simple when you explain it," I said, smiling.

I looked out of the window. A big, plainly dressed man was walking slowly along the other side of the street, looking at the numbers of the houses. He had a large blue envelope in his hand.

"I wonder what that man is looking for," I said.

"You mean the retired sergeant of the Marines," said Holmes.

"He knows that I cannot check his guess," I thought.

Just then the man crossed the road to our door. A minute later he came into our room. "For Mr Sherlock Holmes," he said, and handed my friend the letter.

"May I ask what your job is?" I asked.

"Messenger, sir. Uniform away for repairs."

"And before that?"

"A sergeant, sir, in the Royal Marines. No answer? Right, sir." He saluted and was gone.

The Lauriston Gardens Mystery

I was amazed. "How in the world did you know that?" I asked.

"I could see a blue anchor on the back of his hand, so he had been a sailor," Holmes explained. "But he stood like a soldier, so he was a marine. And he looked used to giving orders, so he had been a sergeant. But look at this." He handed me the letter.

It came from Tobias Gregson of Scotland Yard. During the night a policeman had found the body of a well-dressed man in an empty house, 3 Lauriston Gardens, off the Brixton Road. Cards in his pocket said "Enoch J. Drebber, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A." Nothing had been stolen. There was blood in the room, but no wound on the body.

"Gregson and Lestrade are the best of a bad lot at Scotland Yard," said Holmes. "And they're very jealous of each other. If I solve the case, they'll take all the credit. But we may as well go and have a look. Get your hat."

In the cab Holmes talked happily about violins. "I don't have any facts yet," he said. "It's a big mistake to form a theory before you have all the evidence."

Number 3 Lauriston Gardens was an empty house with a small garden and a yellow clay path. Everything was wet from the night's rain. Holmes did not hurry in. He walked slowly up and down the street, and then along the edge of the path, with his eyes on the ground. Many policemen had walked there, so I could not understand what he hoped to find.

At the door, a tall man with very light hair and a notebook met us. It was Gregson. "Nothing has been touched," he said.

"Except the path!" said Holmes. "A herd of buffalo couldn't have made a bigger mess. Did you or Lestrade come here in a cab?"

"No, sir."

The room was large and empty, with dirty yellow wallpaper. A red candle stood on the mantelpiece. On the floor lay a well-dressed man of about forty-three, with black curly hair and a short beard. On his face there was a terrible look of fear and hatred. I had seen death many times in war, but I had never seen anything so frightening. Lestrade, thin and sharp like a ferret, stood by the door.

Holmes knelt by the body. "You're sure there's no wound?" he asked, pointing to the spots of blood all around.

"Quite sure!" said both detectives.

"Then this blood belongs to a second person, probably the murderer." His fingers moved quickly over the body. Finally, he smelled the dead man's lips and looked at his shiny leather boots.

As four men lifted the body, a ring fell to the floor. Lestrade picked it up.

"A woman has been here!" he shouted. "It's a woman's wedding ring."

Gregson showed us what had been in the dead man's pockets: a gold watch, some money, a book with the name Joseph Stangerson in it, and two letters about ships from Liverpool to New York, one for Drebber and one for Stangerson.

"Have you sent a telegram to Cleveland?" asked Holmes. "Did you ask about anything special?"

"I asked about Stangerson. I've said all I have to say," answered Gregson, offended.

Just then Lestrade came back into the room. "I've made a very important discovery," he said proudly. He lit a match and held it up to the wall in a dark corner. There, where the wallpaper had fallen off, someone had written one word in blood:

RACHE

"The murderer wrote this," said Lestrade. "The writer was going to write the woman's name Rachel, but someone disturbed him. When this case is solved, you'll find that a woman named Rachel was involved."

Holmes burst out laughing. Then he took a tape measure and a large magnifying glass from his pocket. For twenty minutes he moved around the room like a hunting dog searching for a scent, sometimes kneeling and once lying flat on the floor. He measured marks that I could not see and collected a little grey dust in an envelope. Finally, he studied the word on the wall through his magnifying glass.

"You're doing so well that I mustn't interfere," Holmes told the detectives, and his voice was full of irony. He asked for the name and address of the policeman who had found the body: John Rance, 46 Audley Court.

"I'll tell you one thing that may help you," he said at the door. "The murderer was a man more than six feet tall, not old, with small feet for his height. He wore square-toed boots and smoked a Trichinopoly cigar. He came here with his victim in a cab pulled by a horse with three old shoes and one new one. Probably he had a red face, and the nails of his right hand were very long."

Lestrade and Gregson looked at each other and smiled.

"If this man was murdered, how was it done?" asked Lestrade.

"Poison," answered Holmes briefly. "One more thing, Lestrade. 'Rache' is the German word for 'revenge'. So don't waste your time looking for Miss Rachel."

On the way to Rance's house, Holmes explained some of his reasoning.

"I saw the deep marks of a cab's wheels near the pavement. There had been no rain for a week before last night, so the cab came during the night. One hoof mark was sharper than the others: the new shoe. You can tell a man's height from the length of his steps. Also, a man writes on a wall at the level of his eyes, and that word was just over six feet from the ground.

"He crossed a puddle four and a half feet wide in one easy step, so he's not old. The word on the wall was written with a finger dipped in blood, and the plaster was scratched, so the nail was long. And the ash on the floor was dark and flaky. Only a Trichinopoly cigar makes ash like that. I've written a small book about cigar ash."

"And the German word?" I asked.

"A trick to send the police in the wrong direction. It wasn't written by a real German. And inside, Square-toes walked up and down while Shiny-boots stood still. I could read it in the dust. His steps grew longer, so he was getting more and more excited. Then the tragedy happened."

John Rance had been asleep, but Holmes played with a gold coin in his fingers, and the policeman soon told his story.

"At about two in the morning I saw a light in the window of that empty house," he said. "I went to the door—"

"You stopped, and then walked back to the garden gate," said Holmes. "Why?"

Rance jumped in surprise. "That's true, sir! How did you know? It was so quiet and lonely that I wanted someone with me. But there was nobody in the street. So I went back in. There was a red candle burning, and by its light I saw—"

"Yes, I know what you saw. You walked round the room several times, you knelt by the body, then you tried the kitchen door—"

Rance stood up with a frightened face. "Where were you hiding to see all that?"

Holmes laughed. "Don't arrest me. I'm one of the hunting dogs, not the wolf. Go on."

"I blew my whistle, and three more policemen came. The street was empty, except for a drunk man leaning on the railings and singing loudly."

"What did he look like?" asked Holmes quickly.

"A tall man with a red face, the lower part of it covered by a scarf. He had a brown coat. We were too busy to deal with him."

"Did he have a whip in his hand?"

"No."

"He must have left it behind," said Holmes quietly. He gave Rance the coin and stood up. "I'm afraid you'll never get promoted, Rance. Last night you had the man we are looking for in your hands."

In the cab, Holmes was angry. "What a fool! He was so lucky and did nothing with it."

"But why would the murderer come back?" I asked.

"The ring, man, the ring! That's what he came back for, and we can use it to catch him. I must thank you, Doctor. Without you, I might have missed the finest study I ever saw: a study in scarlet. There is a scarlet thread of murder running through the colourless thread of life, and our duty is to find it and follow it to the end."

The Ring in the Newspaper

That afternoon Holmes went to a concert. I tried to rest, but I kept seeing the dead man's face.

"Have you seen the evening paper?" he asked. "It doesn't mention the ring. That's good. Look at this advertisement. I sent it to every newspaper this morning."

The advertisement said: "Found in Brixton Road, a plain gold wedding ring. Ask Dr Watson, 221B Baker Street, between eight and nine this evening."

"But I don't have a ring," I said.

"Yes, you have." He gave me a ring that looked almost the same. "The man in the brown coat will come. He dropped the ring while bending over the body. He came back for it, but the police were already there, so he pretended to be drunk. Now he'll think he lost it in the street, and he'll look in the newspapers. Load your old army revolver. He'll be a desperate man."

When I came back with the gun, Holmes was playing his violin. "I've just had an answer to my telegram to America," he said. "My idea of the case is correct." But he would say nothing more.

At eight o'clock the doorbell rang. We heard slow, uncertain steps on the stairs and a weak knock at the door.

"Come in," I said.

Instead of a violent man, a very old, wrinkled woman came into the room. She looked at us with weak eyes and took a newspaper out of her pocket.

"It's this that brought me here, gentlemen," she said. "That ring belongs to my daughter Sally. She was married a year ago, and her husband is a steward on a ship. She went to the circus last night and—"

"Is this her ring?" I asked.

"Thank goodness! Yes, that's the ring."

"What's your address?"

"13 Duncan Street, Houndsditch. A long way from here."

"The Brixton Road isn't between any circus and Houndsditch," said Holmes sharply.

The old woman looked at him with her small red eyes. "The gentleman asked for my address. Sally lives at 3 Mayfield Place, Peckham."

"And your name?"

"My name is Sawyer. Hers is Dennis."

Holmes signalled to me, so I gave her the ring. She thanked us many times and went slowly down the stairs. At once Holmes ran into his room and came back in a long coat.

"I'll follow her," he said. "She must be working with him, and she'll lead me to him. Wait up for me."

It was nearly midnight when Holmes came home. At first he looked annoyed, and then he burst out laughing.

"I wouldn't want Scotland Yard to know this for anything!" he said. "She took a cab. I heard her give the address, 13 Duncan Street, and I rode on the back of the cab. When we arrived, the driver opened the door, but nobody got out. The cab was empty! And at Number 13, nobody had ever heard of Sawyer or Dennis."

"You mean that weak old woman jumped out of a moving cab without you seeing?"

"Old woman, nonsense! We were the fools for being tricked like that. It must have been a young man, and a fine actor. So our murderer has friends who will take risks for him."

Late into the night I heard the sad music of his violin.

The next morning the newspapers were full of the "Brixton Mystery". Some said it was a political crime by secret societies. One paper reported that Drebber and his private secretary, Mr Joseph Stangerson, had stayed at Madame Charpentier's boarding-house in Camberwell. They had left for Euston Station to catch the Liverpool train, and nobody had seen Stangerson since.

Just then six of the dirtiest, most ragged street boys I had ever seen rushed into the room.

"Have you found it, Wiggins?" Holmes asked their leader.

"No, sir, we haven't."

"Keep looking." He gave each of them a shilling, and they ran off. "Those boys can go everywhere and hear everything," he said. "Ah! Here comes Gregson, looking very pleased with himself."

Gregson ran up the stairs three steps at a time. "Congratulate me!" he shouted. "I've solved the whole case. The man is under lock and key. His name is Arthur Charpentier, a young officer in the Navy."

Holmes smiled with relief. "Sit down and tell us how you did it."

Gregson lit a cigar and laughed. "The best part is that that fool Lestrade is chasing the secretary, Stangerson, who had nothing to do with the crime. Now, you remember the hat by the dead man? I found the shop that sold it, and they gave me Drebber's address: Madame Charpentier's boarding-house.

"I asked Madame Charpentier if she had seen Drebber again after he left for the train. She went white and whispered 'No.' But then her daughter Alice said calmly, 'No good can come from lies, mother. We did see Mr Drebber again.'

"So the mother told me everything. Drebber had been drunk most of the time, and he behaved very badly towards Alice. In the end Madame Charpentier told him to leave.

"Less than an hour after he left, he came back, very drunk. He grabbed Alice by the wrist and tried to pull her out of the house with him. Just then her brother Arthur came into the room. There was a fight, and Arthur drove Drebber out with a stick. Then Arthur said, 'I'll just go after him and see what he does.' He took his hat and left. The next morning they heard about Drebber's death. Arthur came home very late, but nobody knows when.

"So I arrested Arthur Charpentier. My theory is this. He followed Drebber to the Brixton Road, they argued again, and Arthur hit him in the stomach with his stick. That killed him without leaving a mark. Then he pulled the body into the empty house. The candle, the blood, the writing and the ring were all tricks to confuse the police."

"Well done!" said Holmes. "We'll make something of you yet, Gregson."

"Arthur says that Drebber escaped from him in a cab, and then he went for a long walk with an old friend from the Navy. But he can't say where this friend lives. Ah, here's Lestrade!"

Lestrade came in. His face was troubled and his clothes were untidy. "This is a very strange case," he said.

The sample stops here

This is as far as the free sample of A Study in Scarlet goes

You have read 3 of 7 chapters. Start your trial to keep reading all 7 chapters, tap any word for an instant translation, hear the audio narration, and save your progress across devices.

Free sampleTap to translateAudio narration